images (1)

Our brains may make free choices and forced decisions in remarkably similar ways, challenging long-held assumptions about how humans exercise free will, according to new research.

The study, published in the journal Imaging Neuroscience, found that brain activity builds towards a decision in much the same way, whether a person is choosing between several options or has only one option available.

Researchers recorded brain activity while participants chose between coloured balloons. In some trials, they were shown two balloons and allowed to choose freely, while in others they were presented with a single balloon and had to select it.

Participants pressed a button as soon as they made their decision, allowing researchers to track the brain activity leading up to each choice.

In both situations, brain activity followed a similar pattern, gradually increasing until it reached a peak just before the decision was made.

The signal rose more quickly when participants made faster decisions and more slowly when they took longer, suggesting that the brain gradually gathers and weighs evidence before reaching a choice.

The findings challenge the assumption that free decisions rely on fundamentally different neural processes from forced decisions.

Traditionally, scientists have distinguished between free choices, which involve weighing multiple options based on personal preferences, values and goals, and forced decisions, where only one possible outcome is available.

Previous brain-imaging studies have identified different patterns of activity associated with these types of decisions. However, the latest research focused on how decisions are formed rather than simply where they occur in the brain.

The findings also echo earlier experiments by neuroscientist Benjamin Libet in the 1980s, which found that brain activity associated with an action begins before people become consciously aware of their intention to act.

This raised questions about whether the brain begins making decisions before individuals consciously recognise them.

However, researchers say the similarities in neural activity do not necessarily mean personal choices are an illusion.

Although the brain may follow a similar process when making free and forced decisions, the information it evaluates comes from an individual’s preferences, goals and experiences.

As a result, two people may follow similar neural processes but reach decisions for entirely different reasons.

The researchers suggest that understanding free will may require looking beyond how the brain makes decisions to consider what shapes the choices people ultimately make.